How Indiana courts decide custody
What an Indiana judge weighs in a custody case
Indiana courts decide child custody based on the best interests of the child, with no presumption favoring either parent. Ciyou & Associates represents mothers, fathers, grandparents and other caregivers in custody, parenting time, modification and relocation cases across Indiana, and we build every case on a record that will hold up if it is appealed.
Custody in Indiana is governed by statute, and every county applies the same rules. The question is never which parent is better in the abstract. It is which arrangement serves this child, proven with evidence. These are the rules that shape nearly every custody and parenting time case.
The best interests factors
The court must decide custody in the best interests of the child, and there is no presumption favoring either parent. The judge weighs the child's age, the wishes of each parent and of the child, the child's relationships with parents, siblings and others, adjustment to home, school and community, the mental and physical health of everyone involved, and any pattern of domestic or family violence.
Ind. Code 31-17-2-8Legal and physical custody
Legal custody is the authority to make major decisions about the child's education, health care and religious training. Physical custody is where the child lives. A court may award joint legal custody when it serves the child, and treats the parents' agreement as important but not decisive, along with their fitness, ability to communicate and cooperate, the distance between their homes and the child's bond with each parent.
Ind. Code 31-17-2-13 and 31-17-2-15De facto custodians
A grandparent, relative or other person who has been a child's primary caregiver and financial support can qualify as a de facto custodian. The child must have lived with that person for at least six months if under age three, or one year if age three or older. If the court finds this by clear and convincing evidence, the caregiver becomes a party and may be awarded custody.
Ind. Code 31-9-2-35.5 and 31-17-2-8.5The Parenting Time Guidelines
The Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines are presumed to apply in custody cases. For a child age three or older, the baseline for the noncustodial parent is alternating weekends, one weekday evening and a share of every scheduled holiday, plus extended summer time. Parents can agree to more, and the Guidelines include a separate shared parenting plan.
Indiana Parenting Time GuidelinesGuardians ad litem and evaluations
The court may appoint a guardian ad litem or a court appointed special advocate for the child at any time. When a parent asks, the court may order a custody investigation and report, and the report must be shared with the parties before the hearing so it can be tested on cross examination.
Ind. Code 31-17-6-1 and 31-17-2-12Paternity and unmarried parents
When parents are not married, the mother has sole legal custody until a court order or statute provides otherwise. Once paternity is established, a father can ask for custody or parenting time, and the court applies the same best interests analysis used in a divorce.
Ind. Code 31-14-13-1 and 31-14-13-2Sole custody and joint custody describe decision making, not a schedule. Parents can share legal custody while the child lives mostly with one of them, and a 50/50 schedule is possible when it fits the child, the distance between homes and the parents’ ability to cooperate. Whatever the label, the order should say exactly who decides what and when the child is with each parent.
After the first order
Modification, relocation and settling custody disputes
Changing a custody order
A custody order is not permanent, but it is not easy to change. Indiana courts may modify custody only when the change is in the child’s best interests and there has been a substantial change in one or more of the best interests factors. The court will not rehear old history unless it bears on that change. Common examples are a parent’s move, a change in a child’s school or health needs, a teenager’s strong preference, or a pattern of missed parenting time or unsafe conduct. Strong modification cases are built on records, such as school reports, messages, calendars and testimony from people who see the child regularly.
Moving with a child
A parent who plans to move must file a notice of intent to relocate with the court that issued the custody order and serve it on the other parent. The notice is due at least 30 days before the move, or within 14 days of learning about the move, whichever is sooner. A move that brings the parents closer, or adds no more than 20 miles and keeps the child in the same school, does not require notice. If the other parent objects, the court weighs the distance, the cost and hardship of parenting time, whether the child’s relationship with the other parent can be preserved, and the reasons for and against the move.
Mediation and settlement
Many Indiana courts send custody disputes to mediation before a contested hearing. A mediated parenting plan lets parents decide the details that matter to their family, from holiday rotation to school pickups to how decisions will be shared. We prepare clients for mediation the same way we prepare for court, so any agreement is clear, workable and enforceable.
Custody inside a divorce
When parents are married, custody, parenting time and child support are decided as part of the divorce, often alongside property and maintenance questions. Provisional orders set temporary custody while the case is pending, and those early arrangements can shape the final result. If you are facing both issues, read our overview of Indiana divorce as well.
Custody matters we handle
Indiana child custody practice areas
Custody cases rarely stay in one lane. These are the parenting and family matters we handle most often, each with its own page of detail.
Parenting time
Setting and enforcing schedules under the Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines.
Custody modification
Asking the court to change custody after a substantial change in circumstances.
Parenting time modification
Adjusting a schedule that no longer fits the child or the parents.
Relocation
Notice, objections and hearings when a parent wants to move with a child.
Visitation
Protecting a parent's time with a child when visits are denied or disputed.
High conflict custody disputes
Cases involving repeated litigation, safety concerns or a parent who will not cooperate.
Paternity establishment and litigation
Establishing legal fatherhood so custody, parenting time and support can be ordered.
Fathers' rights
Representation for fathers seeking custody, parenting time or a fair support order.
Third party and de facto custody
Custody claims by grandparents, relatives and other caregivers who have raised a child.
Grandparent visitation rights
When Indiana grandparents can ask a court for visitation with a grandchild.
Guardianship and custody
Guardianships for children whose parents cannot provide care.
Interstate custody disputes
Deciding which state's court can hear a case when parents live in different states.
International custody and the Hague Convention
Cases involving a child taken to or kept in another country.
Child support
Calculating, modifying and enforcing support under the Indiana Child Support Guidelines.
College expenses
Requests for parents to contribute to a child's higher education costs.
Custody in divorce
Parenting issues that arise when married parents end their marriage.
Adoption
Stepparent, relative and other adoptions through Indiana courts.
Juvenile delinquency
Defending children and parents in Indiana juvenile court.
Child custody appeals
Appealing a custody or parenting time order to the Indiana Court of Appeals.
Fishers child custody attorney
Local help for Fishers families in Hamilton County.
Carmel child custody attorney
Local help for Carmel families in Hamilton County.
Noblesville child custody attorney
Local help for Noblesville families in Hamilton County.
Westfield child custody attorney
Local help for Westfield families in Hamilton County.
Zionsville child custody attorney
Local help for Zionsville families in Boone County.
Why Ciyou & Associates
Custody lawyers who try cases and handle the appeals
Our firm is based in downtown Indianapolis, and we represent parents and caregivers in custody cases in courts across Indiana. Contested custody has been at the center of our practice for three decades. Every case is personal, and the outcome matters. We start with what you want for your child, then gather the evidence, prepare you for every hearing and keep you informed as the case moves.
Our attorneys also run an active Indiana appellate practice. That changes how we try a custody case. We know what the Court of Appeals looks for when it reviews a custody order, so we build the record, request findings and draft orders with that review in mind. A clear, well supported order is easier to enforce and harder to overturn. If the other side appeals, or the trial court gets the law wrong, the same team that tried the case is ready to take it up.
Your custody team
Bryan has argued in the Indiana Court of Appeals, the Indiana Supreme Court and the Seventh Circuit, and is admitted to the bar of the United States Supreme Court. We also speak Spanish.
Bryan and Kim lead a team of four attorneys, plus paralegals and an intake specialist who keep your case moving. Meet our full team
What Our Clients Say About Us
Questions we hear
Indiana child custody FAQs
The court decides custody based on the best interests of the child, with no presumption favoring the mother or the father. It considers factors such as the child’s age, the wishes of the parents and the child, the child’s relationships and adjustment, the health of everyone involved and any history of family violence.
Sole or joint legal custody refers to who makes major decisions about education, health care and religion. Physical custody refers to where the child lives. Parents can share legal custody even when the child lives mainly with one parent.
Yes, when it serves the child. Indiana has no automatic 50/50 rule. Courts look at the distance between homes, the child’s schedule and whether the parents can communicate and cooperate. The Parenting Time Guidelines include a shared parenting plan for families where equal time works.
No age lets a child decide on their own. The court considers the child’s wishes at any age and gives them more weight once the child is at least 14, but the decision still rests on the child’s best interests.
Under Indiana law the mother of a child born outside of marriage has sole legal custody unless a court orders otherwise. A father must establish paternity before a court can award him custody or parenting time.
File a petition to modify with the court that entered the order. The court may change custody only if the change is in the child’s best interests and there has been a substantial change in one or more of the best interests factors.
A parent who plans to relocate must file and serve a notice of intent to move, generally at least 30 days before the move. The other parent can object, and the court may restrain the move or change custody or parenting time.
Sometimes. A person who has been a child’s primary caregiver and financial support for the required period may qualify as a de facto custodian and ask the court for custody. Grandparents may also seek visitation in some situations.
Talk to an Indiana child custody lawyer
(317) 210-2000
info@ciyoulaw.com
320 N. Meridian St., Suite 600, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Consultations are $250 and are with an attorney.
"*" indicates required fields