In Indiana, custody without a court order depends on marriage. If the parents are married, both parents have equal custody rights until a court rules. If the parents are not married, the mother has sole legal custody until a court orders otherwise, even if the father signed a paternity affidavit. A court order is the only way to change that.
Children are not born with court orders saying who has custody. As long as both parents live together and raise the child, or the mother raises the child alone with the father’s agreement, the lack of an order usually causes no problems. Trouble starts when the parents separate or one parent changes their mind. This guide explains who has custody of a child in Indiana when there is no court order, and what you can do about it.
Who has custody if there is no court order and the parents are married?
When a man is married to the child’s mother when the child is born, or the child is born within 300 days after the marriage ends, he is presumed to be the child’s biological father under IC 31-14-7-1. In that situation, both parents have equal rights to the child until a court decides otherwise.
That equality cuts both ways. If married parents separate and cannot agree, either parent may keep the child, and neither is violating a custody order because none exists. The fix is for one parent to file for divorce or legal separation and ask the court for temporary orders on custody and parenting time.
Who has custody if the parents are not married?
When the parents are not married, Indiana law gives the mother sole legal custody until a court rules otherwise. IC 31-14-13-1 provides that a biological mother of a child born out of wedlock has sole legal custody of the child, with limited exceptions.
A paternity affidavit signed at the hospital or later establishes the father legally, but it does not by itself give him custody. Under IC 16-37-2-2.1, the affidavit form must state that
- if the parents do not check the box agreeing to joint legal custody, the mother has sole legal custody unless a court orders otherwise
- even if they agree to joint legal custody, the mother has primary physical custody unless a court orders otherwise
So an unmarried father who wants parenting time or custody needs a court order through a paternity case.
Can I get full custody of my child without going to court?
This is the most common question we see. The short answer is that you may already have custody without a court case, but you cannot gain or lock in custody rights without one.
| Situation | Who has custody with no order |
|---|---|
| Parents married at birth | Both parents equally |
| Parents unmarried, no paternity affidavit | Mother |
| Parents unmarried, paternity affidavit signed | Mother has sole legal custody unless both agreed to joint legal custody, and primary physical custody either way |
Parents can write their own agreement, but a private agreement that is not approved by a court is hard to enforce. To make an agreement binding, parents usually file it with the court in a divorce, legal separation, or paternity case and ask the judge to approve it.
If there is no custody order in place, can I take my child?
Married parents both have custody rights, so either may generally keep the child until a court enters an order. Unmarried fathers are in a different position because the mother has sole legal custody by law.
Indiana’s interference with custody statute, IC 35-42-3-4, makes it a crime to knowingly take, detain, or conceal a child under 18 with intent to deprive another person of custody or parenting time rights. Taking a child out of Indiana in violation of a court order carries harsher penalties. Because the facts matter so much, talk with an attorney before you take or keep a child from the other parent.
Can one parent keep a child from the other parent without a court order?
In practice, it often happens. When police are called about a parent who will not return a child and there is no order, officers frequently treat it as a civil matter and tell both parents to contact an attorney. The child often stays where they are.
A father who has been absent from the child’s life may find it much harder to see the child, and could face criminal exposure if he takes or keeps the child without the mother’s permission. A father who has been living with the mother and child and sharing care may find police unwilling to step in either way. Either situation is a strong sign that it is time to ask a court for an order.
How do I get a custody order in Indiana?
The right case depends on your family.
- Married parents file for dissolution of marriage or legal separation and can ask for a provisional custody order early in the case.
- Unmarried parents file a paternity action, which lets the court establish paternity, custody, parenting time, and child support.
In either case, the court decides custody based on the best interests of the child under IC 31-17-2-8 for divorce cases and IC 31-14-13-2 for paternity cases. There is no presumption favoring either parent. Judges consider factors such as the child’s age, the wishes of the parents and the child, the child’s relationships, the child’s adjustment to home, school, and community, the mental and physical health of everyone involved, and any pattern of domestic or family violence.
What rights does a parent without legal custody have?
A parent without legal custody can still ask the court for parenting time. Indiana courts generally use the Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines as a starting point when setting a schedule. Once an order is in place, both parents must follow it, and a parent who violates it may face contempt and other consequences.
Why acting early matters
Waiting can make things harder. The longer a child lives in one home without a court order, the more the child’s adjustment to that home, school, and community may weigh in a later custody decision. Filing promptly gives both parents clear rules, protects the child from a tug of war, and creates an order that police and schools can follow.
Frequently Asked Questions
If there is no court order, who has custody of a child in Indiana?
It depends on whether the parents were married. Married parents both have custody rights. If the parents are not married, the mother has sole legal custody until a court orders otherwise.
Can a father take his child if there is no custody order in Indiana?
A married father shares custody rights with the mother until a court rules. An unmarried father does not have custody under Indiana law until a court grants it, and taking or hiding the child to deprive the mother of custody may lead to criminal charges under IC 35-42-3-4. Speak with an attorney before taking action.
Does signing a paternity affidavit give a father custody?
No. A paternity affidavit makes him the legal father, but the mother keeps sole legal custody unless both parents agreed to joint legal custody on the form. Even then, the mother has primary physical custody until a court orders otherwise.
Can we make a custody agreement without going to court?
Parents can agree on their own, but an agreement that a judge has not approved is difficult to enforce. Filing the agreement in a divorce, legal separation, or paternity case turns it into a court order.
Will police help me get my child back without a court order?
Often they will not. Without an order, police commonly treat a custody dispute as a civil matter and send both parents to their attorneys. A court order gives officers something to enforce.
This blog was written by attorneys at Ciyou & Associates, P.C.