In Indiana, the Parenting Time Guidelines tell parents to balance extracurricular activities so they do not unreasonably infringe on either parent’s time. The parent with the child during an activity gets the first chance to drive the child there. If activities keep eating into your time, talk first, then try mediation, then ask the court.
Sports, music lessons, scouting and church groups can be wonderful for children. They can also become a sore spot between parents when practices and games land on one parent’s weekends. Many parents feel the other parent is filling their time on purpose. Others feel pressured to skip activities their child loves. This guide explains what Indiana’s Parenting Time Guidelines say about scheduling activities during the other parent’s time and what you can do when the conflict will not go away.
What do the Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines say about extracurricular activities?
The Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines, last updated effective January 1, 2022, address activities in Section I.D, under Exchange of Information. The commentary to that section says the following.
“Parents should attempt to achieve a balance when scheduling extra-curricular activities. A reasonable amount of extra-curricular activities can enrich the child’s life and strengthen the bond between parent and child through these shared experiences. On the other hand, excessive participation in these activities could serve to diminish the quality of parenting time. Parents should take care to ensure these activities do not unreasonably infringe upon parenting time with either parent.”
The commentary adds that extra consideration should be given to travel activities, such as travel basketball, baseball, softball or soccer, because of the cost, the time away from home and the demands on the child.
Who decides what happens when activities fall on your parenting time?
The Guidelines set several ground rules that apply to both parents.
- Notice. Each parent must promptly tell the other about organized events in the child’s life that allow parent and family participation (Section I.D.3).
- No interference. Neither parent may interfere with the other parent’s chance to volunteer for or take part in the child’s activities.
- Transportation. If an activity happens during one parent’s time, that parent gets the first opportunity to take the child.
- School activities. The parent exercising parenting time is responsible for getting the child to school related activities. The commentary says scheduled parenting time should not be used as an excuse to deny a child’s participation in school activities, including practices and rehearsals (Section I.D.2).
In short, the Guidelines expect a child’s school activities to continue during both parents’ time. Other activities should be reasonable in number and should not swallow one parent’s time.
Does it matter whether you have 50/50 custody?
The same balancing principles apply under a shared parenting plan. With equal time, conflicts can be more frequent because each parent has the child for shorter stretches. Many parents with shared plans agree in writing on how many activities a child may join each season and how new activities get approved. If your order or parenting plan already says how activities are chosen, follow it.
When do extracurricular activities unreasonably interfere with parenting time?
There is no fixed number of hours. Ask yourself honest questions.
- Is your child enjoying the activity, or is your child exhausted and overscheduled?
- Do the activities fall mostly or only on your time?
- Were you consulted before your child was signed up?
- Is the same activity offered on days that would not conflict?
- Can you take part by driving, watching, cheering or helping your child prepare?
Attending your child’s game can be meaningful parenting time. A season of weekend tournaments that leaves almost no time together is a different situation.
What should you do first when activities conflict with your time?
The Guidelines say that when parents disagree about parenting time, “both parents shall make every effort to discuss options, including mediation, in an attempt to resolve the dispute before going to court” (Section I.E.1).
Some tips for that conversation.
- Talk about your child, not about the other parent. Focus on how the schedule affects your child.
- Ask your child how they feel, without putting them in the middle.
- Bring options. Look for other practice times, a different league or a cap on activities each season.
- Assume good faith at first. The other parent may not have planned the conflict.
- Put agreements in writing, even a simple email, so everyone remembers the same plan.
What if you cannot agree?
If conversation does not work, consider mediation. Under Section I.E.2 of the Guidelines, if court action is started, the parents shall enter into mediation unless the court orders otherwise. Some families also use a parenting coordinator, which the Guidelines describe in Section V, to help resolve ongoing day to day disputes.
Can you take the other parent to court over activity scheduling?
Yes, after you have made every reasonable effort to resolve it. A court will focus on your child’s best interests, not on who scheduled what on whose day.
Indiana law gives the court several tools.
- Modifying parenting time. Under IC 31-17-4-2, a court may modify a parenting time order whenever modification would serve the child’s best interests. The court could set rules for how activities are chosen or adjust the schedule.
- Attorney’s fees. Under IC 31-17-4-3, in an action to enforce or modify parenting time, the court may award reasonable attorney’s fees, court costs and litigation expenses. It may consider whether one parent knowingly or intentionally violated the order.
- Contempt. If a court has issued an injunction or restraining order protecting parenting time and the custodial parent intentionally violates it without justifiable cause, IC 31-17-4-8 requires a contempt finding and an order for make up parenting time. The court may also order fees and community service.
Court can be expensive and slow, and the result is never guaranteed. Brief or occasional conflicts rarely justify litigation. A pattern of activities that significantly and unreasonably cuts into your time may.
What about make up time for missed parenting time?
Section I.C of the Guidelines addresses make up time. It says that voluntary choices that prevent a parent from exercising regular time, such as vacations or other voluntary activities, should not be subject to make up time unless both parents agree. If you choose to skip your time because of an activity, do not assume you will get it back. Raise make up time with the other parent first and put any agreement in writing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens when parenting time conflicts with extracurricular activities in Indiana?
The Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines ask both parents to balance activities so they do not unreasonably infringe on either parent’s time. The parent with the child during the activity has the first chance to provide transportation. If the parents cannot agree, they should discuss options and try mediation before going to court.
Can the other parent schedule activities during my parenting time?
The other parent can sign your child up for reasonable activities, and school activities are expected to continue during both parents’ time. Activities should not be so excessive that they swallow your parenting time. If they do, you can raise it with the other parent, try mediation, and ask the court for help if needed.
Do I have to take my child to practice during my parenting time?
For school related activities, the Guidelines make the parent exercising parenting time responsible for transportation, and parenting time should not be used as an excuse to deny participation. For other activities, you have the first opportunity to provide transportation. A court looks at your child’s best interests if a dispute continues.
Can I get make up time if an activity takes my parenting time?
Not automatically. The Guidelines say voluntary activities that keep a parent from exercising regular time generally are not subject to make up time unless both parents agree. Ask the other parent and document any agreement.
Can a parenting coordinator help with activity disputes?
Yes. Section V of the Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines describes parenting coordination, a process where a trained neutral helps parents resolve recurring disputes. It is often useful for high conflict families who argue over schedules and activities.
This blog was written by attorneys at Ciyou & Associates, P.C.