Blog
Denial of a Speedy Trial in Indiana: What It Means Under Criminal Law

Speedy Trial Rights in Indiana and Criminal Rule 4 Explained

Indiana Criminal Rule 4 sets deadlines for bringing a criminal case to trial. A jailed defendant must be tried within 180 days or be released. A jailed defendant who files a motion for early trial must be tried within 70 days. Every defendant must be tried within one year. Delays caused by the defense do not count.

Being charged with a crime is stressful. Waiting months for a trial date can make it worse. Indiana law gives every person accused of a crime the right to a speedy trial, and it puts firm deadlines in writing. This guide explains what those deadlines are, what stops the clock, and what happens when the State misses a deadline.

Where does the right to a speedy trial come from?

The right has three sources.

  • The Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution guarantees the accused a speedy and public trial.
  • Article 1, Section 12 of the Indiana Constitution says justice shall be administered “speedily, and without delay.”
  • Indiana Criminal Rule 4 turns those promises into specific time limits that Indiana trial courts must follow.

The constitutional right protects people from long pretrial detention, from years of anxiety and public suspicion, and from losing evidence or witnesses as time passes. Criminal Rule 4 is the tool most Indiana defendants actually use to enforce it.

What is CR4 in Indiana court?

“CR4” is shorthand for Indiana Criminal Rule 4, titled “Impact of Delay in Criminal Trials.” The Indiana Supreme Court restyled the criminal rules effective January 1, 2024, and the current version has three time limits. Each one starts on the date the charge is filed or the date of arrest on that charge, whichever is later.

  • Rule 4(A), defendant held in jail. Trial must start within 180 days. If it does not, the defendant is released on recognizance, but the charge stays pending.
  • Rule 4(B), jailed defendant files a motion for early trial. Trial must start within 70 calendar days of the motion. If it does not, the charge must be dismissed when the defendant moves for dismissal.
  • Rule 4(C), any defendant, in jail or out. Trial must start within one year. If it does not, the charge must be dismissed when the defendant moves for dismissal.

Rule 4.1 says every calendar day counts, including weekends and holidays. If the last day falls on a day the court is closed, the deadline moves to the next day the court is open.

How fast is a speedy trial in Indiana?

The fastest track is a motion for early trial under Rule 4(B). It is only available to a defendant held in jail. Once the motion is filed, trial must start within 70 calendar days. If the defendant is released from jail before the 70 days run, the early trial deadline no longer applies, though the one year limit still does.

Filing for a fast and speedy trial is a strategic choice. A quick trial date puts pressure on the State. It also gives your own defense team less time to review evidence, interview witnesses and file motions. Talk through the tradeoff with your attorney before you file.

What time is attributed to the defense under CR4?

Not every day on the calendar counts. Rule 4 excludes three kinds of delay.

  1. Delay caused by the defendant. Asking for a continuance, changing attorneys close to trial or filing motions that push back the trial date can all be charged to the defense.
  2. Congestion of the court calendar. A crowded docket can extend the deadline.
  3. An emergency. Events that shut down or limit court operations can stop the clock.

Under Rule 4.1, when a court grants or orders a continuance it must say whether the delay is charged to the defendant, to court congestion or to an emergency. Delay from a continuance is measured from the original trial date to the new trial date. If the defendant causes any delay during the last 30 days of a Rule 4 period, the State may ask for a 30 day extension.

Keep a careful record of every hearing and continuance. Many speedy trial disputes come down to whose delay it was.

Can the State get more time?

Yes, in limited cases. Under Rule 4(D), if the defendant moves for dismissal, the court may continue the trial for 90 days and release the defendant without money bail if the State shows all of the following.

  • There is evidence the State would be entitled to present at trial.
  • The evidence is unavailable right now.
  • The State made a reasonable and diligent effort to get the evidence in time.
  • The evidence can be obtained within 90 days.

If the defendant is not brought to trial within that 90 day period, the charges must be dismissed with prejudice.

What if you are held in another county or out of state?

Rule 4.2, amended effective January 1, 2025, covers defendants charged in one place but held somewhere else. If you are arrested outside Indiana or held in federal custody, the Rule 4 clock starts when you are returned to Indiana or made available for prosecution. If you are jailed in one Indiana county on a charge pending in another county, the clock starts on the earlier of two dates. One is the date the charging court orders your appearance. The other is the date you give that court written notice of where you are and ask it to start proceedings.

What happens if your speedy trial right is denied?

The remedy depends on which deadline was missed.

  • Under Rule 4(A), the remedy is release from jail on recognizance. The case is not dismissed for that reason alone.
  • Under Rules 4(B) and 4(C), the charge must be dismissed once the defendant moves for dismissal.
  • Under Rule 4(D), missing the extended 90 day window requires dismissal with prejudice, which means the State cannot refile the same charges.

Separate from Rule 4, a defendant can argue that the delay violated the constitutional right itself. Courts weigh four factors from the United States Supreme Court decision in Barker v. Wingo, 407 U.S. 514 (1972). They are the length of the delay, the reason for it, whether the defendant asserted the right, and the prejudice the delay caused.

How do you protect your speedy trial rights?

  • Decide early, with your attorney, whether an early trial motion makes sense.
  • Ask your attorney to track the Rule 4 deadlines from the date of arrest or filing.
  • Pay attention when the court sets a trial date. If a date is set outside the Rule 4 period, raise the issue promptly rather than waiting.
  • Think carefully before asking for a continuance, since that time is usually charged to you.

Sometimes a continuance is the better choice. Extra time can let your attorney fully prepare, and a rushed trial does not always lead to a better result.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Criminal Rule 4 in Indiana?

Criminal Rule 4 is the Indiana court rule that limits how long the State can take to bring a criminal case to trial. It sets a 180 day limit for defendants held in jail, a 70 day limit after a jailed defendant moves for early trial, and a one year limit for everyone. Delays caused by the defendant, court congestion or an emergency are excluded.

How long does a speedy trial take in Indiana?

If you are in jail and file a motion for early trial, the trial must start within 70 calendar days, minus any excluded delay. Without that motion, a jailed defendant must be tried within 180 days or released. The outside limit for any defendant is one year from the later of the charge or the arrest.

Does asking for a continuance affect my speedy trial clock?

Usually, yes. A continuance requested by the defense is generally charged to the defendant, which extends the deadline. The court must state on the record whether each delay is charged to the defendant, to court congestion or to an emergency.

How do I request a speedy trial in Indiana?

A defendant held in jail can file a written motion for early trial under Criminal Rule 4(B). Your attorney will usually file it. The 70 day period begins on the date the motion is filed.

Will my charges be dismissed if the speedy trial deadline passes?

It depends on the deadline. Missing the 70 day or one year limit means the charge must be dismissed once the defendant moves for dismissal. Missing the 180 day limit for a jailed defendant leads to release, not dismissal.

This blog was written by attorneys at Ciyou & Associates, P.C.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Email

Table of Contents

Quick Contact

Need to talk now? Fill out the quick form below and we will contact you directly.

What Our Clients Say About Us

Super Lawyers badge recognizing Ciyou and Associates PC for 2027 in Indiana Super Lawyers badge rating Bryan L Ciyou for 2027 in Indiana

Contact Us

Name(Required)