Blog

Legal custody arrangements are meant to give children safety, structure, and the best possible environment to flourish. But life in Indiana isn’t static. New jobs, school shifts, health changes, and the evolving needs of kids, and parents, can create pressing reasons for families to return to court and modify custody orders. Unfortunately, the process is rarely simple, and even cooperative co-parents can get lost in paperwork, statutes, and court calendars.

For parents in Indianapolis, Carmel, Zionsville, Noblesville, Fishers, and throughout Indiana, this expanded resource offers clarity and empowerment. Here, you’ll learn about Indiana’s laws, what “substantial change” really means, how to build a bulletproof case with evidence, differences between mediation and litigation, and what to expect in your local county court. Whether you’re considering a change or responding to a motion from your child’s other parent, this guide puts experience, examples, and step-by-step guidance at your fingertips.

Legal Background: Understanding Indiana Custody Statutes

The Basics: Indiana Code § 31-17-2-21

Indiana law recognizes that families evolve, so custody orders must sometimes evolve with them. However, the state requires a legal showing of both (1) the child’s best interests and (2) a “substantial change” affecting key factors, never one without the other.

The law reviews several “statutory factors,” including:

• The child’s age and gender
• Parents' desires regarding custody
• The child’s wishes (especially at age 14 and up)
• The depth of relationships with parents, siblings, and adults
• School, neighborhood, and community adjustment
• Physical and mental health of all parties
• Any domestic violence history

The overarching goal is child stability and well-being. This “double threshold” prevents unnecessary changes while allowing swift intervention if a child’s safety or basic needs are at risk.​

Statute Nuances and Application

“Substantial” is not just about inconvenience; courts look for enduring, impactful changes:

• Has a parent relocated far enough to disrupt school or medical care?
• Is there credible evidence of ongoing abuse, neglect, or dangerous living conditions?
• Has a health issue dramatically shifted parenting abilities?
• Are there school reports that point to mounting problems?

Even if your situation feels urgent, Indiana judges examine every claim through the lens of current law and recent appellate decisions, balancing continuity and protection for the child.​

How Indiana Courts Interpret Custody Modification, Notable Cases

Understanding statutes is step one, knowing how courts apply those laws is just as important.

Lamb v. Wenning (1991)

One of Indiana’s hallmark decisions, Lamb v. Wenning, clarified that the original custody order stands unless clear proof of a fundamental, ongoing change is presented. Judges demand rigorous evidence that alteration is necessary for the child’s best interests, not simply preferred by a parent. Even disruptions like changed work shifts, minor disagreements, or differences in parenting philosophy rarely justify modification unless they shape the child’s safety or development directly.​

Paternity of T.P. (2016 Appellate Decision)

Judges are reluctant to move children without proof. In T.P., for instance, a parent’s claim that the other was “irresponsible” academically didn’t substitute for hard data. It was declining grades, paired with professional statements from teachers, that persuaded the court that change was warranted. The message is clear: document and prove your concerns with real-world evidence.​

Relocation and the Relocation Statute

Indiana considers relocation as potential grounds for custody modification when the move crosses major county or state lines and impacts the child’s relationship with both parents. Parents must submit a formal relocation notice, and the court will weigh effects on stability, schooling, and access to both homes. Judges often engage court evaluators, consider children's input, and mediate to find the least disruptive solution.​

Building Your Modification Case: Practical Parent Tips and Templates

Step One: Honest Self-Assessment

Before you call an attorney or gather papers, ask:

• Has my child’s home life truly changed?
• Is the other parent unable or unwilling to be present, safe, and supportive?
• Do I have evidence, not just suspicions or secondhand comments?

Step Two: Collect Objective Evidence

This is the bedrock of your case. Gather all the records that demonstrate the pattern you see:

• School attendance and grade reports over several months
• Statements from teachers, coaches, or child care providers
• Medical documents (doctor’s notes, diagnoses, therapy summaries)
• Police or protective services reports (when applicable)

Step Three: Communication Logs

Judges often rely on evidence from court-approved co-parenting apps that track:

• Missed pickups and drop-offs
• Change requests and responses
• Emergency events or schedule deviations (with times and dates)
• Disparaging comments or aggressive communications

Step Four: Professional Assessments

A letter from a child’s physician, therapist, or social worker often carries more weight than a parent’s testimony. Professional assessments showing regression, trauma, or health risks can prompt emergency changes, so collect these early if circumstances warrant.

Step Five: Organize With Templates

Sample Incident Log

Evidence Checklist

• School attendance and discipline records
• Medical/mental health records
• Counseling reports (if relevant)
• Copies of all written communication regarding custody/exchanges

Bring your evidence to an initial attorney meeting so nothing is overlooked and nothing delayed.

Practical Insights: Steps, Preparation, and Local Nuances

In Marion and Hamilton counties, judges may require parents attempt mediation and complete co-parenting classes before bringing modification claims to a full hearing. In more rural counties, expect a lower caseload but fewer resources.

Step-by-Step Guide:

1. Consult a Child Custody Modification Lawyer: A local attorney will know your court’s preferences.
2. Draft and File a Verified Petition: Detail your case as completely as possible.
3. Serve the Other Parent: The court will not proceed without proof of legal notice.
4. Participate in Mediation (if required): Attempt good-faith resolution.
5. Prepare for Hearings: Organize and index all your evidence, line up witnesses.
6. Attend Hearings and Await Decision: Present your best, most child-focused case.

Tips for Pro Se Litigants (Those Without Attorneys)

• Visit the Indiana courts’ self-help website for updated forms and guides
• Some local bar associations operate legal clinics, use them for review before filing
• Practice your main points, and always bring labeled copies of all documents

Mediation vs. Litigation in Indiana Custody Modification

Mediation

Advantages:

• Confidential, encourages creative solutions
• Often quicker and less costly
• Less stressful for children

Disadvantages:

• Only effective with good faith by both parents
• Not suitable in cases of abuse or high conflict

What to Expect:

• Mediation usually wraps within a few sessions. Parents may bring support persons or lawyers. Mediator keeps the focus on the child's needs.

Litigation

Advantages:

• Enforced by court, necessary for emergencies
• All claims are carefully vetted

Disadvantages:

• Potentially lengthy and expensive
• Relationships may further deteriorate

What to Expect:

• Litigation can last months. Both parents must exchange evidence. Judges may appoint guardians ad litem or evaluators.

Practical Strategy:

Start with mediation, unless your situation is urgent or safety is at risk. Judges appreciate parents who attempt to work together first.

Navigating Your County Court System

Marion, Hamilton, and surrounding counties require pre-filing parenting seminars. Guardian ad litem appointments are common for contested cases. Know your local rules:

• Marion County expects detailed, indexed evidence binders at hearings.
• Hamilton County requires mediation in nearly all modification matters.
• Boone/Noble/Smaller Counties: Fewer procedural steps, but more direct judge involvement.
  Always check your county’s latest protocol online.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

• Failing to keep records (every claim needs proof!)
• Missing court deadlines or filing in the wrong jurisdiction
• Making negative public or social media comments about your ex or the court
• Coaching your child on what to say (judges and guardians see through it)
• Withholding visitation as leverage

Consulting a custody attorney reduces risk and increases your chance for a positive outcome.

Expanded Indiana Custody FAQ

If my ex wants to move to another state, can I stop them?
You can object. Courts will hold a hearing, and both stability and the child’s relationships are evaluated. Timely filing is crucial.

Can custody be modified twice, or more?
Yes, if you can prove new, ongoing changes since the last order.

Will my child have to testify?
Usually not. Indiana courts often appoint a guardian ad litem or take private “in camera” statements from older children.

Does it harm my case if I lived with my ex after divorce?
Not automatically. Courts look at patterns, not isolated incidents.

I lost my job, can this justify a change?
It might if job loss means home instability or affects your ability to provide. Judges weigh multiple factors, including efforts to regain employment.

Are there exceptions for domestic violence or imminent harm?
Yes. Courts can hold emergency hearings and issue immediate protective orders.

What if my child refuses to attend visitation?
Parents are expected to facilitate court-ordered time. Chronic refusal may result in further evaluation.

Resources and Support for Indiana Families

• • Indiana Legal Services – Family Law Division
  • Local county self-help centers (search “[your county] family court resources”)
  • Parenting Time Helpline: 1-844-836-0003
  • Mediation directories via local bar or 
  • Indiana Bar Association

• Local Guardian ad Litem and child psychology service providers

Moving Forward: Supporting Your Child’s Best Interests

Your child’s needs will change, and so should their legal protections. Armed with knowledge, records, and determination, Indiana parents can make the strongest possible case for what’s best. Remember, success depends not only on following the statute, but assembling objective proof and approaching each step from the perspective of your child’s future.

If you’re facing or anticipating a custody modification, Ciyou & Associates, P.C. offers expert advocacy and personalized support, serving all of Indiana, including Indianapolis, Carmel, Zionsville, Noblesville, Fishers, and beyond. Connect for a private consultation at (317) 210-2000.

Disclaimer

This blog is provided for informational purposes and is not legal advice. Indiana family law changes frequently, and every case presents unique facts. For advice about your case, consult a qualified child custody modification lawyer in Indiana.

Citations

• Indiana Code § 31-17-2-21
• Indiana Legal Services: Custody General
• Ciyou & Associates: How Mediation Can Influence Child Custody Decisions
• Lamb v. Wenning, 600 N.E.2d 96 (Ind. Ct. App. 1992)
• Ciyou & Associates – Ultimate Guide to Indiana Child Custody Laws
• Indiana Department of Child Services – Child Support